Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘Ramadan’

It started innocently enough.

It was late last night and I was looking at my Facebook news feed. I noticed a picture posted by someone who was attending the Iftar dinner at the White House. I knew this happens every year, and not seeing anything unusual in the picture (except the very large number of “likes”), I quickly scrolled down. Few minutes later, I decided to glance through my Twitter timeline, where I saw the following tweet:

I confess that I was shocked, but only for a brief moment. Of course, this was a valid critique. Why didn’t I think of this when I first saw that picture on Facebook? I felt a slight disappointment for not noticing the moral implications of attending a White House Iftar. I knew I had to atone for my complacency.

How would I respond?

First, even though I believed that the moral critique contained in the tweet by @irevolt was powerful and valid, I could also anticipate that at least some Muslims would become easily distracted by the quasi-fiqhi tone of the tweet and, therefore, they would fail to appreciate the real point. (I’ll have more to say about this issue in my next blog post.)

Second, I decided that I would not say anything too negative or harsh about the folks who attended the White House Iftar. I knew some of them personally, and I knew they were not bad people by any stretch of the imagination. In fact, I knew that according to the usual criteria they were far better Muslims than I was. Clearly, I had no reason whatsoever to doubt their faith, and I was certainly not going to claim that I was somehow better than they.

Third, I thought about their possible motives. Why would they do such a thing? Since I had already decided not to attribute any immoral or hypocritical motive to them, the only option was to assume that they didn’t know the full implications of their choice. I had to assume they were sincere. I must be as gentle and generous with them as possible, because they couldn’t possibly have known what they were doing. We all make mistakes while having the best of intentions.

Fourth, I tried to put myself in the shoes of those who attended the White House Iftar. What would I had done if I was in their position? I decided that the only justification for visiting the President would be to speak the inconvenient truth to him. But that required courage. Did I have that courage? I thought about a recent experience in which I had failed to speak an inconvenient truth in front of people who were far less powerful than the U.S. President; I had remained quiet out of sheer cowardice. I decided that I didn’t have the courage needed to speak the inconvenient truth in a formal White House dinner, where such behavior would also have required breaking all etiquette and protocols, leading to rather unpleasant consequences. I knew I had no reason to demand that other folks must have the courage that I lacked.

Fifth, if I didn’t have the courage to do the right thing, what would have been my options if I were actually invited to the White House? I could have attended the Iftar with the President, followed the required etiquette and protocols, and afterwards enjoyed a celebrity status among my peers. But this would have injured my soul and done serious violence to my conscience. Therefore, lacking the necessary courage to rock the boat but also wanting to preserve my soul and conscience, the only thing I could have done under those circumstances would have been to decline the invitation. Sorry, I would have said to the White House, but I can’t come to your dinner.

In view of the thought process described above, I hope that the tweets I sent out would make better sense:

To summarize, here are the main points I’ve been trying to make:

1. It was not a good idea for any conscientious American Muslim to attend an Iftar in Barack Obama’s White House during Ramadan 2012. The reasons for this should be obvious to anyone who has not been living in a cave, but I will list them anyway in my next blog post.

2. Without questioning the faith or sincerity of a fellow Muslim, the least that can be said about his/her participation in the above program is that it must have been the result either of ignorance or a lack of critical reflection.

3. Cowardice in itself is not a moral defect. If you lack the courage to speak the inconvenient truth in the face of the powerful, you can do the next best thing and avoid being in the company of the powerful.

Comments are welcome, as always 🙂

Read Full Post »

The ninth month of the Islamic calendar, the month of fasting, will commence in a few days. Most Muslims will fast throughout the month, each day from dawn to sunset, as well as many non-Muslims who are beginning to find this practice conducive to their spiritual growth.

What is a typical fast like?  You wake up for a small meal just before dawn; you refrain from eating, drinking, smoking, and sex all day long, until it is time to break your fast . . . at sunset.  There are extra prayers to be offered at night, which further shorten your rest time.

Sounds irrational, doesn’t it?  Why make yourself suffer?

Even though it is rarely introduced as such, there is no denying that suffering is the main feature of the whole exercise.  Fasting is a disciplined and controlled way of frustrating our basic instincts, particularly our needs for food and rest, thereby generating an experience that is highly unpleasant from a biological perspective.  And yet, Ramadan is one of the most anticipated time of the year for Muslims, as well as the most joyful one.

The self-imposed suffering we experience during the month of fasting has one characteristic feature, I think, that makes all its unpleasant aspects worthwhile.  The suffering is supposed to be experienced with maximum awareness.  To merely suffer is not the point; the point is to suffer consciously.

Not everyone, unfortunately, is going to pay attention to this particular feature of fasting; many of us will try to avoid feeling the unpleasant sensations of hunger, thirst,  tiredness, annoyance, irritation, impatience, and so on, that naturally arise in the fasting body-mind.  They will try to immerse themselves in activities, in conversations, in watching movies, in board games . . . with the sole aim of ignoring, avoiding, forgetting these unpleasant sensations.  They will eat bigger and more delicious meals than usual, both before dawn in order to delay the unpleasantness as much as possible, as well as at sunset in order to compensate for all the unpleasantness they have already endured during the day.  If possible, they will take really long naps during the day, sometimes getting more sleep in Ramadan than they are used to getting in the rest of the year.

All of these strategies are aimed at not achieving what seems to be the primary purpose of the entire setup of Ramadan, i.e., learning to consciously suffer.  By using these strategies, many of us will be quite successful in feeling the absolute minimum of unpleasantness, and that too with little or no awareness; with the help of these strategies, we will defeat the purpose.

agent_smithIt so happens that suffering is inevitable for human beings, regardless of how much progress technology makes and how much social engineering we perform to ward off sickness, disappointment, despair, loss, and other unpleasant things.  It is not just that we do not seem to eradicate suffering, but that a complete absence of suffering will not even be acceptable to us.  We won’t be able to live and thrive as humans if we were to find ourselves in a perfect world, a world that lacks all unpleasantness, all suffering.  On this point, let me quote someone with a penetrating insight into the human condition.  I mean, of course, Agent Smith.

Did you know that the first Matrix was designed to be a perfect human world?  Where none suffered, where everyone would be happy.  It was a disaster.  No one would accept the program.  Entire crops were lost.  Some believed we lacked the programming language to describe your perfect world.  But I believe that, as a species, human beings define their reality through suffering and misery.  The perfect world was a dream that your primitive cerebrum kept trying to wake up from.  Which is why the Matrix was redesigned to this: the peak of your civilization.

Despite its unpleasantness, suffering has a positive role in making us who we are, as well as in fostering the conditions and faculties that allow us to become what we are capable of becoming.  There is hardly any point in taking something that is as necessary for the full flowering of our humanity as suffering and making it into our enemy, something to be conquered and eliminated at all costs.

Now, it should be obvious that I am not advocating that you go out of your way to court suffering, nor am I suggesting that all attempts at minimizing it should cease.  The issue, rather, is one of inner attitude.  If something is everywhere, happens all the time, and absolutely no one is immune from it . . . shouldn’t we approach it with respect and even compassion?  Shouldn’t we learn how to experience it, how to benefit from it, how to make it our friend rather than an adversary?  Insofar as suffering can be eliminated, I would say, let’s try our very best to eliminate it.  But insofar as it still remains, I would say, let’s embrace it fully.  If certain forms or degrees of suffering are unavoidable, if they won’t go away no matter how hard we try, then let’s stop trying to push them away.  Let’s treat them as honored guests; there is no need to invite such guests, of course, but if they have already arrived at our doorsteps then let’s welcome them!

Paradoxically, what helps us transcend suffering is not the attitude of enmity, opposition, or war against its purported causes . . . but a deepening of our experience of suffering in all its unpleasantness.  In this background, the pedagogical value of Ramadan lies in the innumerable opportunities it provides for practicing conscious suffering in small, manageable installments.  Experiencing the limited and controlled suffering of fasting is therefore a spiritual practice that prepares us for the kind of suffering that is neither self-imposed nor pre-planned, the kind of suffering that can appear at our doorsteps anytime, without warning.

Read Full Post »